response to those who say heaven and hell will perish ibn taymiyyah

Page 53

النُّورُthe lightالمُعْتَادُ،usual,يَعْرِفُونَthey knowبِهِby itالْبُكْرَةَthe morningوَالْعَشِيَّ،and the evening,كَمَاasتَظْهَرُit appearsالشَّمْسُthe sunلِأَهْلِto the people ofالدُّنْيَا،the world,لَكِنَّbutالْجَنَّةَthe paradiseلَيْسَتْis notفِيهاin itظُلْمَةٌ.darkness.

The usual light, by which they know the morning and the evening, just as the sun appears to the people of this world; but in Paradise, there is no darkness.

وَقَوْلُهُ:And His saying:كَلِمَاتُThe wordsاللَّهِof Allahداخِلَةٌenteringتَحْتَunderالْعَدَدِthe count(١)(1)مَمْنُوعٌis prohibitedإِنَّمَاIndeedيَدْخُلُentersمِنْهَاfrom themتَحْتَunderالْعَدَدِthe countبَعْضَsomeمِنْofأَبْعَاضِهَاits partsمِثْلَlikeالْآيَاتِthe versesالْمُنَزَّلَةِ،revealed,وَإِلَّاand elseفِيْمَاin whatلَاnotنِهَايَةٌan endلَهَاto itكَيْفَhowيَكُونُisمَعْدُودًاcountedوَكُلَّمَاand wheneverعَدَّcountedبِقَدْرٍby an amountمَعْدُودٍcountedفَهُوَitمَاwhatحَدٌّ،is defined,وَمَاand whatيُقَدِّرُهُhe definesالْإِنْسَانُthe humanبِلِسَانِهِby his tongueوَذَهْنِهِand his mindمِنْfromالْعَدَدِthe countفَلَهُfor himحَدٌّ،a limit,وَالَّذِيand that whichلَا يَتَنَاهَىdoes not have an endلَيْسَ لَهُdoes not have for itمِقْدَارٌa measureلَاnoفِيinذِهْنِهِhis mindوَلَاnorفِيinلِسَانِهِ.his tongue.

And His saying: The words of Allah are prohibited to be counted (1). Rather, only some of its parts, like the revealed verses, enter under the count. Otherwise, how can what has no end be counted? Whenever something is counted by a certain measure, it has a limit, and what a person defines by his tongue and mind as a count has a limit. What does not have an end does not have a measure, neither in his mind nor in his tongue.

وَقَوْلُهُAnd His sayingتَعَالَى:the Exalted:{خَالِدِينَ{They are eternalفِيهَاin itمَاas long asدَامَتِit lastsالسَّمَاوَاتُthe heavensوَالْأَرْضُ}and the earth}.(٢)(2)

And His saying, the Exalted: {They are eternal in it as long as the heavens and the earth last} (2).

إِلَّاExceptمَاwhatشَاءَwillsرَبُّكَyour LordإِنَّIndeedرَبَّكَyour Lordفَعَّالٌis All-Activeلِمَاfor whatيُرِيدُ}He wills}.(٣)(3)

Except what your Lord wills; indeed, your Lord is All-Active for what He wills} (3).

قَالَSaidابْنُIbnأَبِيAbiحَاتِم:Haatim:ذَكَرَHe mentionedعَنْfromجَعْفَرJa'farبِنْbinسُلَيْمَان،Sulaiman,عَنْfromالْجُرَيْرِي،Al-Juraiقَالَ:said:سَمِعْتُI heardأَبَاAbuنَضْرَةَNadraيَقُولُ:saying:يَنْتَهِيEndsالْقُرْآنُthe Quranإِلَىtoهَذِهِthisالْآيَةَ:verse:{إِنَّ{Indeedرَبَّكَyour Lordفَعَّالٌis All-Activeلِمَاfor whatيُرِيدُ}He wills}.(٤)(4)

Ibn Abi Haatim said: He mentioned from Ja'far bin Sulaiman, from Al-Jurai, he said: I heard Abu Nadra saying: The Quran ends at this verse: {Indeed, your Lord is All-Active for what He wills} (4).

وَقَدْAnd indeedرَوَىnarratedحَرْبُHarbالْكَرْمَانِي،Al-Karmani,وَأَبُوand AbuبَكْرٍBakrالْبَيْهَقِيAl-BayhaqiعَنْfromأَبِيAbuسَعِيدٍSaeedالْخُدْرِي،Al-Khudri,وَعَنْand fromقَتَادَةَQatadaفِيinقَوْلِهِ:His saying:{فَأَمَّا{So as for(٥)(5)الَّذِينَthose whoشَقُواare wretchedفَفِيso they are inالنَّارِ،the Fireلَهُمْfor themفِيهاin itزَفِيرٌa wailingوَشَهِيقٌand a gaspingخَالِدِينَeternalفِيهَاin itمَاas long asدَامَتِit lastsالسَّمَاوَاتُthe heavensوَالْأَرْضُand the earthإِلَّاexceptمَاwhatشَاءَwilledرَبُّكَ}your Lord}.(٦)(6)

And indeed, Harb Al-Karmani and Abu Bakr Al-Bayhaqi narrated from Abu Saeed Al-Khudri, and from Qatada regarding His saying: {So as for those who are wretched, they are in the Fire; they have in it a wailing and a gasping, eternally in it as long as the heavens and the earth last, except what your Lord willed} (6). Allah knows best related to its duality as it has occurred (7).

وَاللَّهُAnd Allahأَعْلَمُknows bestبِتَثْنِيَتِهِregarding its dualityعَلَىconcerningمَاwhatوَقَعَتْhas occurred.

And Allah knows best regarding its duality as it has occurred (7).